Our wonderful tech support specialist Andrea helped Rachel troubleshoot this issue and here's the outcome:
This Macbook Pro is connected to an external monitor, keyboard and mouse, with multiple displays set-up. BFP will not function in this "external" environment. To get BFP working, Andrea turned on display mirroring in system preferences. This tells the Macbook pro to display exactly what is on the main laptop’s screen and not to use a virtual display.

Rachel - Thanks for your patience. Andrea - Thanks for getting this solved!!!